HP Lovecraft Books: Three Ways to Complete Your Collection
Wednesday, September 14, 2011
Buying H.P. Lovecraft books to complete a collection is a previously unimaginable experience, thanks to the diverse options now available. From the humble days when HPL’s fiction was tightly controlled by Arkham House, to the explosion of Lovecraft at the publishing presses ever since his work passed into public domain, offering have expanded at a stunning rate. Still, there are only three quick and easy ways to complete a Lovecraftian collection, or at least come extremely close to it. Use these books to complete your personal collection of Lovecraft’s dark fantasies in a cost effective way.
Necronomicon: The Best Weird Tales of H.P. Lovecraft
Two fat volumes from Gollancz represent the cheapest way to bring together the Providence author’s best known and most obscure writings. Necronomicon: The Best Weird Tales of H.P. Lovecraft binds together his most well respected efforts, from the fragmentary “Night Gaunts” to late, complex novellas such as “At the Mountains of Madness.” This nearly nine hundred page tome is one heavy paperback, but it is sturdily constructed and nicely illustrated.
With the arrival of Eldritch Tales: A Miscellany of the Macabre, Gollancz has created a high quality companion volume that taps Lovecraft’s lesser known pieces. In this book, HPL’s juvenile pieces, poetry, and important non-fiction tie ins like “Supernatural Horror in Literature” and “The History of the Necronomicon” cross paths. An excellent sampling of his collaborative and ghost written stories are thrown in for good measure.
Both gigantic volumes are edited by Stephen Jones and illustrated by Les Edwards. Together, they represent the quickest and cheapest path to collecting all of Lovecraft with the fewest books possible.
The Del Rey Lovecraft Collections
Throughout the 1990s and into the early 2000s, Del Rey’s H.P. Lovecraft books represented a widely acceptable way to obtain his tales in a mass market form. Though these collections are extraordinarily cheap on the mass market, you’ll need four Del Rey books to complete a Lovecraft collection. The big themed collections begin with The Best of H.P. Lovecraft: Bloodcurdling Tales of Horror and the Macabre, a book clearly designed to draw in newcomers.
Under the Del Rey imprint, the saga continues with The Road to Madness and Dreams of Terror and Death: The Dream Cycle of H.P. Lovecraft. These H.P. Lovecraft books constitute themed volumes built around his early fiction and dream addled tales, respectively. They chart an affordable path to a comprehensive collection, and the cover art by Michael Whelan remains nothing short of iconic.
Most recently, Del Rey’s fourth book came out, granting readers access to Lovecraft’s collaborations and ghost written pieces. The Horror in the Museum does what a only more expensive Arkham House book was previously able to do. If you’re willing to throw bibliophilic preferences to the wind, snapping up this volume with the other three Del Rey collections is a great way to get all Lovecraft essentials onto your shelves.
H.P. Lovecraft: Masters of the Weird Tale
Centipede Press is the Lamborghini quality publisher of the horror world, and that extends to their gigantic tome, H.P. Lovecraft: Masters of the Weird Tale. Don’t think of this 1200 page Cyclopean terror as just a very expensive hardcover. It herds together all Lovecraftian necessities into a slipped case deluxe edition, and pairs it with a separate book of rare HPL photography unavailable elsewhere.
The only downfall of H.P. Lovecraft: Masters of the Weird Tale is that it may only be a high end avenue to getting nearly all H.P. Lovecraft books in one for a limited time. Centipede Press has limited this museum of a book to three hundred copies. Unless that changes, this miniature Lovecraft library will probably slide into the hands of a few hundred lucky collectors, and live on only as legend. At least, until the next deluxe press dares to place Lovecraft’s fiction into an equally outstanding presentation.
H.P. Lovecraft books will undoubtedly continue to multiply as the years pass. However, shortcuts that let you complete your collection will probably remain modest, well kept secrets, available only to true Lovecraft fanatics.
-Grim Blogger



9 comments:
I would most certainly NOT recommend the error-riddled Del Rey volumes, of which only The Horror in the Museum and Other Revisions is worth owning (it is an exact reproduction of the corrected Arkham House text).
And why do you not mention the book published by Barnes & Noble, H. P. Lovecraft: The Complete Fiction? It actually has ALL of Lovecraft's solo fiction, and now that there is a corrected edition (the previous ones were horribly riddled with errors), it can finally be recommended with a clear conscience.
Is there a reason you didn't include either the Penguin paperbacks or the Barnes and Noble hardcover? Just wondering, as those're the two I have (in addition to two of the Del Reys).
I honestly thought the Lovecraft/Bishop collaboration THE MOUND made THE HORROR IN THE MUSEUM worth checking out. It definitely makes my top five Lovecraft tales. Lovecraft’s significant contribution to THE MOUND seems very obvious, and there seemed to be a little hint of romance in the story that may have come from Bishop that just ended up being crushed by Lovecraft’s macabre sense of storytelling.
@Nathaniel: I hope you didn't get the old printings of the B&N book, since they are riddled with errors. Only the latest printing can be recommended.
Your idea of a complete Lovecraft collection is very different from mine. I think that such a thing should include all of his:
1) Fiction (including revisions)
2) Essays
3) Verse
4) Surviving Letters
Of course, no person (with any shred of sanity) could currently aspire to this collection. The greatest barrier to achieving such a thing is that many (most?) of his surviving letters remain unpublished.
I have assembled, though, what I consider to be the-nearest-a-sanish-person-can-currently-assemble-to-a-complete-Lovecraft-collection. Troubling to go up to my bedroom, just now, I thought to count 58 volumes each of which added something to Lovecraft's complete work. I may well have miscounted, but don't believe that the thing could be assembled in very many fewer volumes.
Amongst the more obvious additions to Lovecraft's work are the 5 volumes of the Selected Letters, and the 5 volumes of the Collected Essays.
Amongst the less obvious is Crypt of Cthulhu 46, which includes Lovecraft's letters to Adolphe de Castro. These (as far as I know) have never appeared elsewhere.
I've had the Arkham House hardcovers since the late '80s (after I ditched my cheap Del Rey paperbacks), and just recently purchased their HORROR IN THE MUSEUM. I also have that amazing B&N COMPLETE FICTION edition! I haven't read anything in that edition however so I don't know about any errors - what were they, exactly? Spelling? Editing? Wrong versions? I know I have the first edition.
@Pet: 58 volumes? It should be possible to do it in much less.
* The 5 basic Arkham House volumes of stories
* 3 Penguin volumes (of which the last one is necessary to get the corrected versions of "Hypnos" and "The Shadow out of Time"; not necessary anymore since the corrected B&N volume appeared)
* The B&N book (to get the long version of "The Mysterious Ship")
* The Necronomicon Press booklet of "The Challenge from Beyond" (for the complete text of this story, not just Lovecraft's segment)
* Eyes of the God (to get the rare "Hoard of the Wizard-Beast" and "Slaying of the Monster"; however, the text of "The Night Ocean" included here is very unreliable)
* The Ancient Track (to get the poetry)
* Lovecraft Annual #3 (to get the poetry that didn't make it into The Ancient Track
* The Grill-Binkin Catalogue (to get the 4 lines of poetry that didn't make it into any of the above)
* The 5 Collected Essays volumes
* Lovecraft Annual #4 (to get the short version of "Some Notes on a Nonentity)
* various collections of letters of which I'm missing only the two volumes of Bloch letters; about 18 volumes in total (Hippocampus Press will do all of the preserved letters in 20-25 volumes, though)
@Will: If you've got the first edition the only thing that is amazing about it is the lack of proofing: misspelled words, words added, words dropped, half a sentence dropped, commas changed, semicolons changed, "Bibliothèque" spelled "BibliothS¥que", "coöperate" spelled "co,,perate", and so on and so on. Go to http://www.hplovecraft.com/writings/sources/hplf.asp and download the errata list and see for yourself. The most recent printing has been corrected (there's still one error in it that I discovered too late, though).
Thank you all for your suggestions. Having looked over the B & N edition, I will include it when I update this post. I, too, was put off by the misprints and typos in earlier editions.
The Penguin Paperbacks were not included because I dislike the physical quality of the books. I'm not sure what it is, but every Penguin book I've owned, Lovecraft and otherwise, has started to deteriorate pretty quickly. This is a real shame, since they are very good annotated editions by S.T. Joshi. But the paper quality bites.
The rest of you guys are spot on to mention the letters and poetry that constitute a TRUE Lovecraftian collection. However, this article is meant as more of a general guideline for newcomers to Lovecraft, and those who want to bulk up their collections of his fiction. Only the true die hards will try to collect every shard of HPL every printed, as we all know.
Post a Comment